West of Route 12 and north of Big Hollow Road, behind the Jewel-Osco, there used to be a gravel pit. The land was marketed for commercial use for years and drew little interest, according to the Daily Herald. The reason was simple. Drivers on Route 12 had a hard time seeing it, and getting in and out was difficult.
Today that land is The Residences at the Quarry, a $40 million, 154-unit market-rate rental community laid out in 11 townhouse-style buildings. The first building was ready for occupancy on October 1, 2026. It is the first new multifamily project to go vertical in Fox Lake in 15 years.
The way it got built tells you something useful if you are comparing Fox Lake with other towns along the border. The housing Fox Lake says it lacks is the kind the market has not produced here without help. For someone shopping now, that shapes what is actually available.
A site the commercial market passed on
A market analysis of the quarry property found that housing was its best use. The site sits right next to existing retail, including the Jewel-Osco to the south, and its limited access and low visibility from Route 12 made it a weak candidate for stores. A site that works poorly for shops can work well for homes. Residents don't need to be seen from the highway, and having groceries within walking distance helps.
Even with the site settled, the numbers still had to work. That is where public financing came in.
What the public side contributed
The village used tax increment financing, or TIF, to support the project. The Daily Herald reported that in a TIF, property values in a designated area are frozen for up to 23 years for local governments such as school and park districts. Tax revenue from new development above that frozen amount is set aside for development-related costs. For the Quarry, the developer's eligible costs were capped at about $9 million.
A second incentive came through Lake County Partners, the county's economic development organization. It secured an enterprise zone designation, which offset sales taxes on construction materials. Lake County Partners describes that designation as part of what made the project financially viable.
Both the builder and the mayor have said plainly that the project depended on this help. Kevin Micheli, president and COO of Charles Hall Construction, told the Daily Herald the project would not have been built without the incentives. Mayor Donny Schmit said the same about the TIF, in the same report:
"That was a blighted property — it used to be a gravel pit. Without the TIF this project wouldn't have been possible."
That says a lot about the local market. On a $40 million project, the TIF agreement allowed up to about $9 million in eligible developer costs, and both the builder and the mayor say the project would not have happened without that help.
The gap, in the village's own words
Mayor Schmit described the shortage to the Daily Herald. Fox Lake has expensive lakefront homes, and he said about 72% of the village's housing stock is considered affordable. "We don't need any more affordable housing," he said. "What we need to do is fill that gap in the middle."
The village's Comprehensive Plan, adopted in November 2025 and posted on the village planning page, describes the stock in more detail:
- Building types: a semi-dense mix of cottages, bungalows, ranches and split-levels on narrow, tree-lined streets, with a smaller number of apartments, townhomes and condominiums
- Ownership: 69 percent of homes are owner-occupied, and rentals have grown over the past 15 years, including short-term rentals for tourists
- Age: more than half of the homes were built before 1980
- Cost pressure: 26 percent of homeowners and 49 percent of renters spend more than 30 to 50 percent of their income on housing
The plan calls for new multifamily housing, especially for seniors and moderate-income residents, along with rehabilitation programs to keep the older homes in good shape. In stakeholder sessions, people raised concerns about aging homes in the inner part of the village that need maintenance. They held a range of views on multifamily housing but broadly agreed that new housing should raise the quality of life.
For a buyer, this is the practical takeaway. If you want something newer with an attached garage and less upkeep in Fox Lake, there are few homes like that for sale. The middle-priced homes on the market are mostly older single-family houses, and many of them will need updating over time. Where the newer middle-type product does exist, at the Quarry, it is for rent.
What the rents show about that middle
The rents give the clearest picture of where the "middle" sits. When the project was proposed, the Daily Herald's October 2025 coverage listed projected rents of $1,568 to $2,541 a month. When the first tenants moved in, the posted range had narrowed.
| Monthly rent range | Source date | |
|---|---|---|
| Projected at proposal | $1,568 to $2,541 | October 2025 |
| Posted at opening | $1,995 to $2,295 | October 2026 |
The low end of the range rose by more than $400, and the high end dropped by more than $200. As of mid-October 2026, Fox Lake's new middle-market housing rents for roughly $2,000 to $2,300 a month.
The layout explains part of that price. Units range from one to three bedrooms in a townhouse-style design, and about 57% come with attached garages. The community also has a clubhouse, a fitness center, a dog park and outdoor recreation space. The Comprehensive Plan says the village has very little of this kind of housing.
If you are weighing renting first against buying right away, these rents are a local benchmark you can compare with a monthly ownership cost. Freddie Mac's average 30-year fixed rate was 7.18% for the week of November 5, 2026, so any comparison should use current numbers.
The buildings arrive in stages
The project is opening one building at a time. As of the builder's mid-October schedule:
- October 1, 2026: the first of 11 buildings was ready for occupancy, and six tenants had moved in by mid-October.
- November 1, 2026: the target date for a second building.
- The months after: one to two buildings a month, according to the builder.
- Spring: expected completion. Lake County Partners notes that some buildings will welcome residents in 2027.
Micheli told the Daily Herald the project has been "getting a lot of traction" with many showings. How quickly the remaining buildings fill over the winter will show whether demand for the middle is as strong as the village believes.
Downtown is where the village tries this next
The Quarry sits near big-box retail at the south end of the Route 12 corridor. The Comprehensive Plan's longer-term goal is closer to the center of town. It describes downtown Fox Lake, along Grand Avenue toward Nippersink Lake, as having Main Street-style buildings, the Metra Milwaukee District North station and the newly upgraded Lakefront Park. It also says downtown is widely seen as needing significant investment. The plan points to room for denser development around the Metra station and better walking and biking connections across Route 12 to the lakefront.
The tool for that is a transit-oriented development zoning update. It covers parts of West and East Grand Avenue and Nippersink Road from the lakefront to Grand Avenue, including the Metra station area. Its stated goals are to connect downtown to the lakefront, lower commercial vacancy, and redevelop underused and vacant sites to bring more housing and walkability. The project is funded by a $35,500 RTA grant. As of its October 2026 status update, draft amendments had gone to the steering committee, the Planning and Zoning Commission and the Village Board, design guidelines had been drafted, and more presentations were planned for the last quarter of 2026.
Several sites have come up in the village's planning. The 2013 Station Area Plan identified the former Goodyear site as a possible location for a future Metra parking garage, with the Goodyear building reused at ground level. The 2025 Comprehensive Plan points to the end of Grand Avenue west of downtown and the closed Mineola Hotel site to the east as places where public lakefront access could expand.
The Quarry is the template the village has to work from. A site the commercial market passed over became middle-market housing once public financing filled the gap, and it is renting at about $2,000 a month. Downtown sites near the station come with their own hurdles, and the zoning update is how the village will set the terms for whatever gets built there.
The TIF and enterprise zone details above are general information drawn from public reporting, not legal, tax or financial advice. If a decision depends on them, please confirm the specifics with the right professional.
If you're deciding between an older Fox Lake ranch or bungalow and renting at the Quarry while you get to know the area, I'm happy to walk through the tradeoffs with you, including what to look for in a pre-1980 home before you write an offer. Reach out to Jessica Grieser and let's connect.